Black Lives Matter movement in Australia: First Nations perspectives

Is “defund the police” appropriate in an Australian context?

Peta MacGillivray, a Kalkutungu and South Sea Islander lawyer and researcher, currently serves as the Yuwaya Ngarra-li Project Manager based at UNSW Sydney. In her area of work, Ms MacGillivray said the police have been allowed to lead a lot of community safety, innovations and efforts, while the government view is that police are the best people to be doing this work.

“That’s just not the case. We know that so much of what amounts to better outcomes in community safety comes from community solutions and community-led approaches to dealing with these challenges,” said Ms MacGillivray.

She is also concerned about the language of “defund the police” as this can lead to a monetary discussion about investment and equating reducing communities down to an economic value.

Alison Whittaker, a Gomeroi poet and legal researcher from the floodplains of Gunnedah in NSW, said the “defund the police” movement makes sense in the context of the United States where police forces are much more locally controlled and have much more discreet budgets.

She says addressing the issue in Australia requires thinking like that of Ruth Wilson Gilmore, a prison abolitionist and prison scholar, who calls it a transformation.

“Abolition doesn’t just mean defunding, although that’s a critical step and making sure these institutions can’t do the harm that they do and ensure also that they’re kind of on the way out as we build communities,” said Ms Whittaker.

Not only are communities ready, but they are also capable, said Ms Whittaker: they have plans, but they’re not getting resourced because of the focus on policing, law and order which can undermine community attempts to get ahead.

“’Defund the police’ is a fantastic slogan, it works,” said Ms Whittaker.

“But here it requires something more substantial and not just of parts of policing law and police powers, but the actual policing logic of the law in Australia.”

The Australian Law Reform Commission’s Pathway to Justice Report

The Australian Law Reform Commission’s Pathway to Justice Report supports a justice reinvestment approach in Australia and says this is a crucial element of addressing high levels of imprisonment of Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander peoples.

Ms MacGillivray has concerns about this report and justice reinvestment as she says it gave too much primacy to neoliberal ideas – which acquainted communities only valuable and worthy of effort if it came to their cost saving.

While prisons are being expanded and the NSW police force is growing and supported through multimillion-dollar training facilities, Ms MacGillivray said the attention should be on how policy is being developed, led by states and jurisdictions.

Current approaches focus on the justice system – as if solutions can be found in the systems which created the problems, said Ms MacGillivray.

“We know that the drivers of incarceration are outside of that, and solutions are certainly outside of that,” she said.

When talking about policing and incarceration, Ms Reid said it can’t just be a number-crunching exercise.

It is a “really complex bureaucracy” for First Nations peoples to navigate and push back on when it comes to policing their communities, she said.

“When it comes to trying to shift the narrative in these communities, we need to be talking about how First Nations do not just have a say on a slogan or a policy. We need to be talking about how First Nations are sitting at the table, having integral power-shifting decisions about their communities, both at the jurisdictional level and the federal level.”

One of Ms Reid’s aims is to improve accountability for poor political decisions that are not made in the interests of First Nations.

“We are currently in a so-called democracy that functions and flourishes on incarcerating us when we have absolutely no say, as First Nations people, in the systems and the laws about us.”

“We need to be talking about changing society, about reimagining what kind of country we want to live in. And that has to start with power, actual power in the hands of First Nations.”